Category: Case comment

Oct 15, 2026

Safety Rule Defense Fails Where Employer Tolerated Violation

IL Applies Saunders Acquiescence Exception to Footwear Rule An Illinois appellate court, in a decision not designated for full publication, has affirmed an award of benefits to an ice cream...

Safety Rule Defense Fails Where Employer Tolerated Violation Safety Rule Defense Fails Where Employer Tolerated Violation
Oct 13, 2026

Co-Employee Assault Claim Survives Exclusivity

NC: Pleasant Exception Applied to Supervisor’s Alleged Blows The Court of Appeals of North Carolina affirmed the denial of a supervisor’s motion to dismiss a superior court suit by a...

Co-Employee Assault Claim Survives Exclusivity Co-Employee Assault Claim Survives Exclusivity
Oct 12, 2026

The Loose Donkey

NY Court Affirms Heart Attack Claim Where Carrier’s Late Notice of Controversy Left Treating MD’s Causation Opinion Unrebutted New York’s Appellate Division, Third Department, has affirmed a Workers’ Compensation Board...

The Loose Donkey The Loose Donkey
Oct 8, 2026

Three Elements, Not Four

WI Court Holds Prima Facie Case for Refusal to Rehire Injured Worker Needs No Showing of Motive or Application The Wisconsin Court of Appeals has affirmed an award of lost...

Three Elements, Not Four Three Elements, Not Four
Oct 7, 2026

Two Boxes Checked “No”

LA Second Circuit Affirms Forfeiture for False Answers on Pre-Hire Questionnaires About Prior Work Accidents and a Recommended Surgery Louisiana’s Second Circuit Court of Appeal has affirmed a ruling that...

Two Boxes Checked “No” Two Boxes Checked “No”
Oct 5, 2026

Louisiana Court: Paid a Percentage, Still an Employee

LA Fourth Circuit, 3–2, Holds Dump-Truck Driver Paid 25% of Truck Earnings Was an Employee Despite 1099; Dissent Invokes Manifest-Error Review The Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit recently reversed...

Louisiana Court: Paid a Percentage, Still an Employee Louisiana Court: Paid a Percentage, Still an Employee
Sep 29, 2026

Alcohol Falls Outside KY’s Presumption of Causation

KY Supreme Court Holds the Statutory Presumption Against Recovery for Intoxicating Substances Does Not Apply to Alcohol The Kentucky Supreme Court has affirmed benefits for a traffic flagger who was...

Alcohol Falls Outside KY’s Presumption of Causation Alcohol Falls Outside KY’s Presumption of Causation
Sep 28, 2026

The Heart Has Wiring, Too

FL First DCA Holds Harlem’s Narrow “Heart Disease” Definition Does Not Bar a Firefighter’s Arrhythmia Claim Under the Heart-Lung Presumption Florida’s First District Court of Appeal has affirmed an award...

The Heart Has Wiring, Too The Heart Has Wiring, Too
Sep 24, 2026

“Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New

Oregon Court Applies New Claim-Closure Requirements to Case Pending on Judicial Review The Oregon Court of Appeals has held that 2022 amendments limiting retroactive “medically stationary” determinations apply to a...

“Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New “Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New
Sep 22, 2026

Whose Work Was Being Done?

Federal Court: Gas Producer That Hired Out Well Casing Is Casing Worker’s Statutory Employer Under Pennsylvania Law A federal district court in Pennsylvania has held that a natural gas producer...

Whose Work Was Being Done? Whose Work Was Being Done?
Sep 21, 2026

Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided

CO Court of Appeals: No “Change in Condition” Reopening Unless Compensability Was Admitted or Determined Before Closure A Colorado appellate court has held that a workers’ compensation claim closed for...

Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided
Sep 17, 2026

Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper

PA Commonwealth Court Affirms Employee Status Over Contractor Paperwork, Dissent Presses the Payroll Audit The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, sitting en banc, affirmed a finding that a satellite-dish installer was...

Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper