Category: Case comment

Sep 24, 2026

“Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New

Oregon Court Applies New Claim-Closure Requirements to Case Pending on Judicial Review The Oregon Court of Appeals has held that 2022 amendments limiting retroactive “medically stationary” determinations apply to a...

“Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New “Closed” Under Old Rules, Reprocessed Under New
Sep 22, 2026

Whose Work Was Being Done?

Federal Court: Gas Producer That Hired Out Well Casing Is Casing Worker’s Statutory Employer Under Pennsylvania Law A federal district court in Pennsylvania has held that a natural gas producer...

Whose Work Was Being Done? Whose Work Was Being Done?
Sep 21, 2026

Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided

CO Court of Appeals: No “Change in Condition” Reopening Unless Compensability Was Admitted or Determined Before Closure A Colorado appellate court has held that a workers’ compensation claim closed for...

Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided Reopening a Claim Nobody Had Yet Decided
Sep 17, 2026

Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper

PA Commonwealth Court Affirms Employee Status Over Contractor Paperwork, Dissent Presses the Payroll Audit The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, sitting en banc, affirmed a finding that a satellite-dish installer was...

Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper Employee on the Job, Contractor on Paper
Sep 14, 2026

Ten Years, One Claim

D.C.’s Highest Local Court Splits 2-1 on Whether a Single Timely Filing Can Keep a Workers’ Compensation Claim Alive Through a Decade of Silence In a panel decision, the District...

Ten Years, One Claim Ten Years, One Claim
Sep 10, 2026

Blackout Behind the Wheel

Indiana Holds That Driving at Highway Speed Increased the Risk of a Fainting Spell, Making the Resulting Crash Injuries Compensable The Indiana Court of Appeals has affirmed an award of...

Blackout Behind the Wheel Blackout Behind the Wheel
Sep 8, 2026

PA’s AMA Guides Law Beats Back a New Kind of Challenge

State Court Rejects Three Constitutional Theories Against Its Impairment-Rating Statute — Including One Never Tested Before A Pennsylvania appeals court has affirmed a modification from total to partial disability benefits...

PA’s AMA Guides Law Beats Back a New Kind of Challenge PA’s AMA Guides Law Beats Back a New Kind of Challenge
Sep 4, 2026

Sixteen “Matches,“ No Fraud

NY's Third Department Affirms the Board's Rejection of a § 114-a Finding Built on Mismatched Database Hits Yesterday, the Appellate Division, Third Department affirmed a Workers' Compensation Board decision finding...

Sixteen “Matches,“ No Fraud Sixteen “Matches,“ No Fraud
Sep 1, 2026

KY Supreme Court Clarifies Timing of Employer’s Subrogation Credit After Third-Party Settlement

The Kentucky Supreme Court has held that an employer’s statutory right to recover workers’ compensation benefits from an employee’s third-party settlement takes effect immediately, rejecting an argument that would have...

KY Supreme Court Clarifies Timing of Employer’s Subrogation Credit After Third-Party Settlement KY Supreme Court Clarifies Timing of Employer’s Subrogation Credit After Third-Party Settlement
Aug 31, 2026

Florida Court Clarifies Standard for Reimbursing Guardianship Expenses in Comp Claims

The First District Court of Appeal has reversed a Judge of Compensation Claims who applied too narrow a standard in denying a claimant reimbursement for the costs of obtaining a...

Florida Court Clarifies Standard for Reimbursing Guardianship Expenses in Comp Claims Florida Court Clarifies Standard for Reimbursing Guardianship Expenses in Comp Claims
Aug 24, 2026

Waiving a Defense You Never Actually Argued

Utah Supreme Court Says a Pleaded Notice Defense Dies if the Employer Never Asks the ALJ to Rule on It The Utah Supreme Court has held that an employer waives...

Waiving a Defense You Never Actually Argued Waiving a Defense You Never Actually Argued
Aug 19, 2026

VA: One Basket, Two Injuries—and Only One Compensable Accident

In *Sairafianpour v. Loudoun County Public Schools*, 2026 Va. App. LEXIS 430 (Aug. 11, 2026), the Court of Appeals of Virginia affirmed a Workers’ Compensation Commission decision awarding medical benefits...

VA: One Basket, Two Injuries—and Only One Compensable Accident VA: One Basket, Two Injuries—and Only One Compensable Accident